Cliché Essay Topics and How to Fix Them

Crafting a compelling college admissions essay is a critical step in the application process. Your essay is an opportunity to showcase your unique personality, experiences, and aspirations to admissions officers. However, selecting the right topic is crucial to ensure your essay makes a positive impact.

While it’s important to share personal stories and demonstrate resilience, some topics can be challenging to navigate effectively. This guide aims to highlight subjects that are often better avoided or approached with caution. The goal is not to completely steer clear of personal or challenging experiences but to approach them thoughtfully and ensure they highlight your growth and lessons learned.

Nuance is key. Admissions officers come from diverse backgrounds and are looking for essays that provide insight into your character and potential contributions to their community. By focusing on specific lessons, avoiding generalizations, and choosing topics that resonate, you can create a memorable and impactful essay. This guide will help you identify topics that may hinder your application and offer advice on how to frame your experiences in a way that truly stands out.

📹 Watch video

Cliché Essay Topics and How to Fix Them

Crafting a compelling college admissions essay is a critical step in the application process. Your essay is an opportunity to showcase your unique personality, experiences, and aspirations to admissions officers. However, selecting the right topic is crucial to ensure your essay makes a positive impact.

While it’s important to share personal stories and demonstrate resilience, some topics can be challenging to navigate effectively. This guide aims to highlight subjects that are often better avoided or approached with caution. The goal is not to completely steer clear of personal or challenging experiences but to approach them thoughtfully and ensure they highlight your growth and lessons learned.

Nuance is key. Admissions officers come from diverse backgrounds and are looking for essays that provide insight into your character and potential contributions to their community. By focusing on specific lessons, avoiding generalizations, and choosing topics that resonate, you can create a memorable and impactful essay. This guide will help you identify topics that may hinder your application and offer advice on how to frame your experiences in a way that truly stands out.

1. Résumé/Laundry List of Your Life and Achievements

• Avoid: "I’m an expert in time management. I was the president of three clubs, captain of the soccer team, and maintained a 4.0 GPA throughout high school."
• Fix: Focus on a singular experience that shaped you significantly.
• Example: "Founding the Lincoln Douglas Debate Club taught me the value of diverse perspectives. We hosted a community debate series, which encouraged open dialogue and critical thinking among students, fostering a more inclusive school environment."

2. Sports Injury, Challenge, or Success

• Avoid: "Winning the state championship was the highlight of my high school career. We worked hard and deserved the victory."
• Fix: Highlight unique personal growth resulting from sports.
• Example: "My soccer injury led me to discover a passion for coaching. Unable to play, I mentored younger players, focusing on teamwork and strategy, which taught me leadership and adaptability."

3. Immigrant Story

• Avoid: "Learning a new language and adapting to new customs were challenging, but I eventually fit in."
• Fix: Focus on a specific, unique experience within the immigrant journey.
• Example: "After moving to the U.S., I lacked transportation and walked to school daily. These walks sparked my ambition to create a local program providing transportation support for new immigrants."

4. Tragedy – Death, Divorce, and/or Childhood Abuse

• Avoid: "The death of my grandmother taught me that life is short and we must cherish every moment."
• Fix: Focus on personal growth and concrete actions taken.
• Example: "After my grandmother's passing, I committed to volunteering at a hospice, where I learned the importance of empathy and compassionate care, which solidified my desire to pursue a career in medicine."

5. Working Hard in a Challenging Class

• Avoid: "I struggled in my AP Physics class but eventually succeeded through hard work and perseverance."
• Fix: Highlight how the class inspired broader interests or future goals.
• Example: "Struggling in AP Physics ignited my passion for solving complex problems, leading me to start a peer tutoring program that fosters a collaborative learning environment."

6. A Person You Look Up To

• Avoid: "My father taught me the value of hard work and perseverance."
• Fix: Focus on how their influence shaped your own actions.
• Example: "Inspired by my father's dedication, I initiated a community garden project that brought neighbors together, promoting sustainability and local engagement."

7. Short-Term Volunteer/Mission/Church Trip

• Avoid: "During my two-week trip to build houses in a developing country, I realized how fortunate I am."
• Fix: Write about a specific, impactful moment from the trip.
• Example: "During my volunteer trip, I started a podcast to share the stories of local community members, which became my passion and led to advocacy for sustainable development projects."

8. Moving to a Different Part of the Country

• Avoid: "Moving to a new city was challenging, but I eventually made new friends and adjusted."
• Fix: Focus on the personal growth resulting from the move.
• Example: "After moving, I joined the gymnastics team despite being known as uncoordinated. This challenge pushed me out of my comfort zone and taught me resilience and self-acceptance."

9. Your Religious Institution or Faith

• Avoid: "My faith is very important to me and has shaped who I am."
• Fix: Share a personal experience reflecting your relationship with your faith.
• Example: "Leading youth group discussions at my church helped me develop my communication and leadership skills, inspiring me to pursue a degree in community organizing."

10. Romantic Relationships and Breakups

• Avoid: "Breaking up with my boyfriend was heartbreaking and taught me a lot about relationships."
• Fix: Highlight the personal growth or traits demonstrated.
• Example: "After my breakup, I focused on self-improvement and started a peer support group, helping others navigate their emotional challenges and building a strong support network."

11. Family Pressure to Pursue a Particular Major or Field

• Avoid: "My parents want me to become a doctor, and I feel pressured to follow their wishes."
• Fix: Discuss how you developed your own interests and independence.
• Example: "Despite my family's expectations, I pursued my passion for environmental science by leading a research project on local water quality, showcasing my commitment to making a difference in my community."

12. Summer Camp Experiences

• Avoid: "Attending summer camp was fun and I made a lot of new friends. It was a great way to spend my summer."
• Fix: Highlight specific skills or insights gained.
• Example: "At summer camp, I discovered my passion for environmental conservation. Leading a project to restore a local wetland taught me about ecosystem dynamics and the importance of preserving natural habitats. This experience motivated me to pursue a degree in environmental science and contribute to global conservation efforts."

13. Describing a Vacation

• Avoid: "My family vacation to Europe was amazing. We visited many historical sites and I learned a lot about different cultures."
• Fix: Highlight a transformative experience or insight gained from travel.
• Example: "During a trip to Italy, I was captivated by the preservation of historical art and architecture. This inspired me to start a local project focused on restoring and promoting our town’s historical landmarks, merging my passion for history and community service."

14. Learning to Drive

• Avoid: "Learning to drive was a significant milestone for me. It gave me a sense of freedom and responsibility."
• Fix: Use the experience to illustrate a deeper personal development or broader theme.
• Example: "Teaching my younger sibling to drive highlighted the importance of patience and communication. This experience encouraged me to pursue a career in education, where I hope to inspire and guide students through their own learning journeys."

15. Pet Stories

• Avoid: "Adopting my dog was the best decision ever. He has brought so much joy and taught me responsibility."
• Fix: Focus on a unique aspect of your relationship with pets or an initiative related to animals.
• Example: "Volunteering at the local animal shelter, I initiated a pet therapy program for senior citizens. Seeing the joy and comfort pets brought to them, I was inspired to study veterinary medicine to further explore the healing power of animals."

16. Mundane Academic Assignments

• Avoid: "Writing my term paper on World War II was challenging, but I learned a lot about history."
• Fix: Highlight how a specific academic project or assignment influenced your perspective or future goals.
• Example: "Researching my term paper on World War II, I uncovered personal stories that were not in the textbooks. This sparked my interest in archival research, leading me to intern at a local history museum where I help uncover and preserve untold stories."

17. Writing About Legos

• Avoid: "Building with Legos as a child made me realize my passion for engineering. I spent hours creating different structures and vehicles."
• Fix: Focus on current, sophisticated experiences in engineering.
• Example: "My interest in engineering was solidified during my high school robotics club, where I designed and built a robot that won a regional competition. This hands-on experience taught me the importance of teamwork, problem-solving, and perseverance, and inspired me to pursue a career in mechanical engineering."

18. Winning an Award

• Avoid: "Winning the science fair was a proud moment for me. It showed that hard work pays off."
• Fix: Emphasize the journey and growth leading up to the achievement.
• Example: "Preparing for the science fair, I faced numerous setbacks in my project on renewable energy. Each challenge taught me resilience and creativity in finding solutions. This process deepened my passion for sustainable technology, and I am now committed to developing innovative energy solutions."

19. A Mission Trip

• Avoid: "During my mission trip to a developing country, I helped build schools and felt like I was making a difference."
• Fix: Reflect on personal growth and lasting impacts of the experience.
• Example: "My mission trip to a rural village opened my eyes to the complexities of sustainable development. Working alongside local residents, I learned the importance of cultural sensitivity and long-term planning in community projects. This experience inspired me to study international development and pursue a career in creating sustainable solutions for underserved communities."

20. Moving on from a Friendship

• Avoid: "Losing my best friend in middle school was tough, but it taught me the value of true friendship."
• Fix: Focus on the deeper impact and lessons learned.
• Example: "When my best friend moved away, I struggled with loneliness but eventually found strength in new social dynamics. I became more open to making new friends and started a peer mentorship program at my school, helping others navigate social changes and build supportive relationships."